Suicide Among Adoptees and First/Birth Parents: What Does the Research Show?

I hear heartbreakingly often about adoptees who have died by suicide. I heard about one just today.

I do not want to pathologize adoptees or first/birth parents. I realize that many or most may not struggle with suicide or suicidal ideation. Still. We know that sometimes death by suicide is not reported as having been specifically by an adoptee, or as a cause of death at all. We know that many folks outside the adoption community are shocked that an adoptee would choose to die this way, because many folks have a Hallmark idea of adoption, and a lack of awareness that some (not all) adoptees struggle mightily with trauma, whether their adoptive family is loving or not.

And we know that research is scarce, not only about the role of suicide for adoptees but certainly also for birth/first parents.

A new study came out recently: Long-Term Mental Health Effects of Mother–Child Separation Due to Adoption. The author is Lynn Roche Zubov, Ph.D., a first mother in reunion. Dr. Zubov recently retired as a Professor of Education at Winston-Salem State University in North Carolina, U.S.

From the Abstract: “Data were collected from 1313 adoptees, first mothers, and first fathers. Study results indicate that adoption has lasting adverse effects on both adoptees and first mothers. Adoptees and first mothers are significantly more likely to attempt suicide (35 times and 37.7 times, respectively), abuse alcohol, display hypersexual behaviors, and restrict their eating compared to their peers.”

Those numbers, 30+% more likely to attempt suicide, are frightening, and have engendered a lot of discussion.

Via AdoptionUK: “At a YouTube webinar organised by the UK-run Adult Adoptee Movement, Dr Zubov explains that her study was conducted predominantly in the US through recruitment via Facebook groups and forums, with some international participants. 

Notably, the sample includes adoptees who were removed at birth and who had no reported experiences of neglect or abuse in their first families (except, potentially, in utero). Dr Zubov suggests that the experience of growing up away from birth parents presents significant challenges for many adoptees in its own right, additional to or separate from experiences of early neglect or abuse. This hypothesis echoes the language of adoptees such as Zara Philips as well as psychotherapists and doctors with an interest in adoption, including Paul Sunderland and Dr Gabor Maté. 

On the YouTube video, Dr Zubov shares that adoptees in this sample reported higher rates of mental health challenges compared to the general population. In terms of emotional distress, 82.7% of the respondents answered “yes, definitely” to the question of whether they experience pain and loss, and 55.7% reported a pervasive lack of belonging. Approximately 80% of adoptees reported using “unhealthy coping mechanisms” to manage complicated feelings.”

The data and results have been the subject of much discussion. Take a look at a few viewpoints: a Reddit conversation; an academic research blog “Adoption and Suicide Attempts: A Quick Re-Analysis;” a LinkedIn post by Dr. Liz DeBetta, an adopted person and Ph.D.; a Thread by Brooke Randolph, LMHC, LIMHP, LPC, LPCC-S; a therapist and “adoptee ally;” and a Facebook post on First Mother Forum.

A beautiful beach at sunset with vibrant orange and yellow hues in the sky, reflecting on the water. Silhouettes of people can be seen walking along the shoreline.

Please do your own research and reflection on the study as well. Note that there is a difference between suicide attempts and suicide itself. While there’s a fair amount of information out there, we need more research.

Here are a few resources:

A 2022 study asked “What about trauma? Accounting for trauma exposure and symptoms in the risk of suicide among adolescents who have been adopted.”

A 2022 Australia study: INTERCOUNTRY ADOPTION AND SUICIDE IN AUSTRALIA: A Scoping Review

A commonly quoted study prior to Dr. Zubov’s paper was from 2013, from the American Academy of Pediatrics: Risk of Suicide Attempt in Adopted and Nonadopted Offspring.

A 2006 report from Sweden suggested that “Increased risk of suicidal behaviour in non-European international adoptees decreases with age.”

Finally, we all need to learn about suicide prevention, and decrease the fear of talking about it. Take a look at the International Association for Suicide Prevention, and Suicide Awareness Voices of Education. We need to share the 988 hotline here in the U.S. We need to listen and learn.


Adoptive Parents and Estrangement

Estrangement in adoption is a tough, somewhat taboo topic.

It’s real. It affects many parents and adult adoptees. Research shows that many families experience estrangement, and adoptive families fall into that sphere.

Adoption Mosaic’s Navigating Estrangement class for adoptive parents is now open for registration. We start on Wednesday April 28 and meet for 8 weeks. I am a co-facilitator, along with adoptees Becca Flatt and Jenna Lowe.

Graphic promoting a program titled 'Navigating Estrangement' aimed at helping adoptive parents with healing, starting on April 28, 2026. Features a background of twine and the logo of Adoption Mosaic.

The idea for this class evolved from our work in Adoption Mosaic’s Seasoned Parents course, geared to adoptive parents whose children are over 18 (and often are much older). The parents want to learn how to better communicate with their adult children about adoption, including issues such as race, the adoption industry, the role of gratitude, the complexity of parenting. I have co-facilitated the class three times. We talk about why we chose adoption, about how adoption has changed over time, about the role of race in our children’s lives and our own, and about the fact that issues in adoption don’t end when a child turns 18.

In fact, sometimes the issues manifest in different ways as our children get older. And communicating with a 35 year old adult is very different from communication with a 15 year old.

We have had adoptees ask (or insist that) their parents to take the Seasoned Parents class; some adoptees have done the same for the Estrangement class. You can contact Astrid Castro (Adoption Mosaic’s founder and CEO) and schedule a free 15 minute consultation to talk about how to approach this, and to answer any other questions.

You can register for Navigating Estrangement here.

There are many resources provided in the class. There are also many resources about estrangement available to the community via Adoption Mosaic.

Adoption Mosaic runs a program for estrangement adoptees as well: Adoptee Beacon.

Being in community can make such a difference. Please feel free to share this info! Many thanks.

Another International Adoptee, This Time From Iran, Faces Deportation

An adoptee brought to the U.S. decades ago by a U.S. military officer and his wife now faces deportation.

According to the Adoptee Rights Campaign (ARC; their press release is included below), she has no criminal history, and has spent almost her entire life in the U.S. My guess is that she entered the U.S. as an adoptee with a visa that perhaps was not approved for citizenship. Fewer than 200 children have ever been adopted from Iran to the U.S. I don’t think there ever was a formal program. I’d guess that many adoptions were of relatives, and then perhaps also situations like this, adoptions by U.S. military personnel. The U.S. cut ties with Iran almost 50 years ago, and adoptions likely ended then too. I have no special knowledge or insights about this adoptee’s situation. I do know she cannot prove U.S. citizenship, though I would bet that she has made every effort.

The adoptee has no connections with Iran, a country listed as Level 4 by the U.S. State Department: “Do Not Travel advisory, indicating the highest risk due to crime, terrorism, civil unrest, kidnapping, or armed conflict. Citizens are urged to avoid these areas, and in some, the U.S. government has extremely limited ability to provide assistance.”

Yet this is where the U.S. government is considering sending an adoptee, who is without citizenship through no fault of hers.

As an adoptive parent, I am heartbroken that this could happen. We know that adoptees who are deported receive no support once they are out of the U.S. They are dumped off, and left to fend for themselves, often not knowing the language, not having any work possibilities, not having family or friends. We know at least one has died through homicide; at least one has died by suicide. Most deported adoptees are struggling and lonely. Like many of us, they do not understand why the United States deports international adoptees.

Indeed, the United States is the global leader in deporting (and threatening to deport) international adoptees.

While all international adoptees to the United States deserve citizenship, they didn’t get “automatic” citizenship until the Child Citizenship Act of 2000, and that was only for adoptees 18 and younger. Many international adoptees from many different countries are without citizenship–folks in their 30’s on through their 80’s and beyond, Some know they don’t have citizenship, and they are worried. Some assume they are citizens.

Here is important information from the Adoptee Rights Campaign:

***MEDIA ADVISORY & PUBLIC NOTICE***

Contact: Info@adopteerightscampaign.org

Los Angeles, CALIFORNIA— Daughter of U.S. Military Hero Faces Deportation to Iran, Advocates Call for Urgent Legislative Action

Legal advocates, faith-based leaders, and community members are urging protections for a California resident who was brought to the United States by her American parents after her birth in Iran.

Despite being raised by U.S. citizen parents and having no memories of her country of birth, the woman is currently in active immigration removal proceedings that threaten to deport her to Iran, where the U.S. has lacked diplomatic ties since 1979. Her father, a decorated WWII U.S. Air Force veteran, survived a German POW camp and death march before bringing her home to the U.S.

For the past 30 years, the woman, a California resident, has been an integral part of her local community. She graduated from a California university, built a career in the health industry, and is a tax-paying professional. She has no criminal history.

“I have no home other than this country,” she says. “I was raised by my American parents and with American values. To be told that I am suddenly a stranger here, and to be threatened with lifetime exile to a country I know little of, is terrifying.”

Iran is reportedly facing the worst human-rights crisis in years, with security forces violently cracking down on nationwide protests through lethal force, mass killings, arbitrary arrests, and an unprecedented surge in executions.

Legal advocates are asking federal officials to exercise prosecutorial discretion and correct her records, given her extraordinary circumstances, lifelong U.S. residency, and American family history.

The Human Cost of Legal Gaps

Legal experts say that her case highlights a devastating “gap” in protections for children who were brought to the U.S. before modern adoption reforms were enacted. “This is a heartbreaking, obscene failure of a broken system,” says Emily Howe, lead counsel. “Sending a woman who is culturally and socially American, a daughter of a U.S. military hero, to Iran—a nation hostile toward those with Western ties—is a fundamental injustice. We seek compassion and basic correction to protect these American families in the 21st century.”

🚨 CALL TO ACTION: PROTECT AMERICAN FAMILIES

​The long-term solution lies in federal law. The Protect Adoptees and American Families Act (PAAF Act), introduced in 2025 as H.R. 5492 and S. 2923, aims to close the loopholes that allow American-raised children to face deportation. However, the pending bill does not include children who were brought into the country by their American parents on certain visas decades ago.

We are calling on all concerned citizens to take immediate action to ensure no more daughters or sons of American families are cast out!!!

​1. Contact Your Members of Congress: Call or email your U.S. Representative and Senators.

2. ​Message: Urge them to co-sponsor and pass the Protect Adoptees and American Families Act (H.R. 5492 / S. 2923).

3. Demand Inclusion: Ask that the legislation be strengthened to include protections for those who entered the U.S. on visas decades ago and have been raised as Americans.

###

Here’s a resource from The Ties Program that may be of interest to adoptees and adoptive parents: Intercountry Adoptee Rights and Safety Guide: What to Know in 2026.

How Does the Recent U.S. Freeze on Visas from 75 Countries Affect International Adoptees?

President Trump recently announced that immigrant visas from 75 countries are being frozen; “the freeze, which takes effect on 21 January, targets applicants officials deem likely to become a ‘public charge’ – people who they believe may rely on government benefits for basic needs.”

The freeze thus affects international adoptees in the process of being adopted: they are considered immigrants seeking permanent U.S. citizenship.

Temporary visas are not included in the freeze. That’s why visitors for the World Cup will be fine as well as other tourist, student, and business visas.

The freeze affects folks who are looking to be in the U.S. permanently, such as Permanent Residents (green card holders) who can work here, collect Social Security, travel internationally and return to the U.S., file taxes, and obey all laws. Green card holders over the age of 18 must carry their green cards at all times.

International adoptees typically travel with an IR-3 or IR-4 (Immediate Relative) visa or an IH-3/I-H 4 (Immediate Hague) visas.

Those adoptee visas are frozen now.

Of the 75 countries for which immigrant visas are currently frozen, about 20 are currently open to international adoption. The numbers of adoptions from those countries are for the most part small. Some of the countries have signed The Hague Convention on Intercountry Adoption; some have not. A list of Hague countries is here. Some have signed The Hague treaty and are not open to adoption now.

The bottom line is that the U.S. government has frozen adoption-related visas from countries such as Colombia, Brazil, Ghana, Jamaica, Nigeria, Thailand, Cameroon, Haiti, and others. I have no idea how many children are currently designated for international adoption from any of those countries. It’s probably in the low hundreds, I’d guess.

In any case, their visas are frozen, since adoptees fall into that category of immigrant seeking to be in the U.S. permanently who could become “public charges,” meaning they might need long-term institutional care or care that is otherwise long-term for basic needs, like long-term Medicaid.

An Ethiopian little girl in a white dress walks along a road near green trees.
Personal photo by Maureen McCauley

Children with special needs, many of whom are adopted to the U.S., could fall into this category of potentially needing long-term care. “Special needs” is a phrase that covers correctable medical conditions (cleft palate, some heart ailments), or physical conditions which may not be correctable but are more easily managed in the U.S. than in countries of origin. These might include limb differences, cerebral palsy, spina bifida, blindness, for example. Special needs can also include emotional and developmental needs, some of which emerge over time. Trauma–such as separation from one’s mother, country, and culture; abuse and neglect; exposure to violence; natural disasters; housing of food insecurity– is often part of adoption. Obviously, not all people with special needs ever become “public charges” or need long-term care.

While international adoption numbers have declined in recent years, due to fraud, corruption, increased costs, trafficking, stricter regulations, more emphasis on in-country adoption, some countries still send children with special needs, often called waiting children (this could include sibling groups) for international adoption). I realize this is not always the case, but many of these children get far better care here than they otherwise would have.

The current visa freeze ends that possibility. There is no suggestion at this point that there will be an exception for adoptees.

What will be the outcry about this?

One reason I am curious is because of a parallel with the deportation of adoptees. International adoptees without U.S. citizenship have not been exempt from deportation.

Our country has shown virtually no interest or compassion about the notion that international adoptees, brought with the legal permission of the sending country and the U.S, to be here forever, should not be subject to deportation.

That we deport international adoptees is, to me, a shameful tragedy. It seems similarly tragic that we are now banning adoptions particularly of vulnerable children. Yet it is also consistent in terms of U.S. policy, supported by our federal government.

Info About Proving Citizenship for Adoptees and Adoptive Parents: Be Informed, Be in Community

Many of us here in the US are worried about adoptees these days, those whom we love and those who are in the adoption community. The ICE raids, the sweeps at schools and courthouses, the characterization of Somali immigrants as “garbage,” the end of Temporary Protected Status for Ethiopians and others, the banning of travelers from 39 countries (most from Africa): it’s a lot to take in. Add to that the tragic death of Renee Good, the divisive rhetoric in our country, and the suspicion with which immigrants are treated, and you can understand why anxiety and fear are in the air.

International adoptees are immigrants, and many are concerned, as are their adoptive parents.

I heard today about an adoptive parent whose young adult child was held by ICE for about 45 minutes, The adoptee, fortunately, had a Certificate of Citizenship, and that ended the time with ICE. Even so, I’d bet it was a scary time for that young international adoptee. I know of a mom who worries about her daughter waiting at a bus stop. I know adopted adults who say they are looking over their shoulder on a regular basis. Those in Minnesota are particularly, understandably, anxious. I heard from an adoptive parent that she didn’t realize that the Enhanced Driver’s License (available in 5 states) provides both identity and proof of citizenship.

Most adoptees have citizenship, but not all, especially those who were over 18 when the Child Citizenship Act was passed, providing automatic citizenship to international adoptees. I highly recommend all international adoptees get their Certificate of Citizenship (CoC), the gold standard to prove they are U.S. citizens.

Even with the CoC, many adoptees and adoptive parents want to be sure they are doing all they can in the event they get in trouble with the law, or they are caught up in a sweep, or are otherwise challenged to prove their citizenship. Maybe they will not have any issues or challenges–that would be wonderful. And there’s nothing wrong with being prepared.

American flag

I’ve put together some info about government documents that prove citizenship and identity, about Temporary Protective Status which ends February 13 for Ethiopians, and about ideas for phone security and for carrying around government-issued documents. I hope folks will find it helpful. It has a disclaimer, as I am not an expert nor an attorney. I’ve had a lawyer look at it; any errors are mine. Let me know if it needs corrections–thank you.

We need information, and we need community. We need folks to know that they are not alone, and that includes deported international adoptees. I hope all international adoptees have accurate information, and are safe. I hope all adoptive parents will stay informed and supportive of their children, whether the children are in elementary school or are working, married, homeowners, adventurers, whatever the case may be. As an adoptive parent and as a grandmother, I know there is so much we don’t have control over once our children leave the house, whether to live across the country or to ride the bus to school.

Take good care, all.

Wishing Mike Davis a Very Happy Birthday–And Hoping for Good News

Happy 63rd Birthday, Mike!

Today must be bittersweet at best.

Mike is an Ethiopian adoptee, raise by his U.S. Army adoptive dad on military bases. Mike settled in Georgia. He got married, had children, and ran various businesses.

Over 30 years ago, he got into trouble with the law. He served his time, and has had no trouble with the law since then.

As is true for too many adoptees today, Mike was unable to prove his citizenship, despite his dad’s efforts: documents had been lost, government agencies failed to respond, and his lawyers were unreliable and uniformed about adoption and immigration laws. Mike was deported back to Ethiopia in 2005, and been separated from his friends and family since then. He has yet to meet his grandchildren in person.

We started a GoFund Me for Mike in June 2023. Mike is deeply grateful to all who have donated.

Mike Davis is an older man, smiling, wearing a red tee shirt and black jacket.
Mike in Addis in 2023

A total of $5250 has been raised over the last two and half years. Mike has used about $5000 of it, so roughly $2500 each year, to cover rent, food, access to water, legal fees, and medical care. His other sources of income are minimal at this point.

While that $210 a month goes fairly far in Ethiopia, it’s not much. He lives a hard life. His efforts to attain citizenship have involved document fees, lawyer fees, and more, at U.S. prices. It’s been an uphill climb in many ways.

Many folks in the adoption community want to let Mike know he has not been forgotten. Mike has had a rough time in Ethiopia, though he does not complain. He had no friends, no money, and no work when he arrived 20 years ago. He’s done his best to survive alone. Safe housing, food, and medical care haven’t always been easy to find. He’s dealing with health issues now in his early 60’s.

Please help. Donations have slowed significantly, and inflation/expenses are rising these days in Ethiopia.

Please join me in wishing Mike a Happy Birthday, and donate to our GoFund Me. Please share the GoFundMe with others.

So many people support international adoption. Please support international adoptees as well, in this case a now-63 year old man who made a mistake over 30 years ago, and who believed (as many adoptees do) that he had citizenship (he paid taxes, he paid into Social Security). His wife, his sons, and his grandkids would love to have him back.

Mike is a good person. Adoptive families and adoptees have met up with him in Addis, which has brought him great joy.

As a community, I invite everyone to wish Mike a good birthday, and to send your prayers, blessings, and hopes that he might return to the U.S., which was supposed to be his forever home.

Many thanks. Amasegenallo (thank you in Amharic).

Please also support the valuable work of Adoptees for Justice, who have helped Mike and many other adoptees in positive, productive ways. They are a hard-working, amazing organization.

Adoptee Remembrance Day 2025

Today is Adoptee Remembrance Day, designed to honor and remember adoptees who have died, who have been deported, who are survivors of the Troubled Teen Industry, who are incarcerated, who have been abandoned after being adopted, and those dealing with mental illness and/or substance abuse. We honor and remember all the forms of loss in the adoption community.

My post today is drawn essentially from my 2024 post about Adoptee Remembrance Day. The reasons for the day remain the same, and I am grateful for all those, especially adopted people, who promote awareness and the need for this day.

In the words of Pamela Karanova, the U.S. adoptee who founded Adoptee Remembrance Day, “While our primary goal is to uplift the legacy of those who are no longer with us, we also seek to share the truth of how adoption has impacted each of us. October 30th is our day of truth, transparency, and remembrance—a day for adoptees around the world to come together and be seen.”

What can you do to observe this day? There are many wonderful suggestions here. I’ve drawn some ideas below from the Adoptee Remembrance page. Please consider these actions, and share them with others.

  • Pause for a moment of silence for adoptees who have died.
  • Donate to help Mike Davis, who was adopted by a U.S. Army officer and was deported to Ethiopia in 2005. He has never met his grandchildren, and hasn’t been his wife and children for many years.

Twelve years ago yesterday, the parents of Ethiopian adoptee Hanna Williams were sentenced to lengthy jail terms for Hanna’s death. So many of keep Hanna in our hearts.

Adoptee Remembrance Day is “a beacon of awareness, remembrance, and solidarity.” Deep gratitude to those who work tirelessly to help and support adopted people around the globe.

Post on ICE Detaining Latina U.S. Citizen Adoptee Gets Big Numbers (For My Blog)

On October 15, I posted about a U.S. citizen detained by ICE. Maria Greeley is an adoptee, born in the U.S.. She is Latina, and may well have fit a certain racial profile for ICE detention and zip ties.

Mine is a small blog. I appreciate each of my readers very much; they are not a large group in comparison to others.

Yesterday alone, 592 visitors took a look at my blog; 590 of them looked at the Maria Greeley post. That’s wild for a single day on my blog. If anyone knows anything more, such as who picked up and shared my post, that would be great to know.

In any case, I am heartened by the fact that this news is getting out, via me and via many other sources. Thank you! The fact that a U.S. citizen was detained by ICE because her Irish-sounding adoptive family name did not fit her brown appearance is an ominous harbinger of sorts for many adoptees, including those not born in the U.S..

Check in on your adoptee community, your children, your friends. Acknowledge their concerns, especially if they are black or brown, about the ICE raids. If they are looking for advice, suggest that they carry a passport card, or a photocopy of their passport. Suggest they memorize the name and phone of an immigration lawyer. They may not need any of that; I hope I am being overly-cautious.

Let them know that you are thinking of them, especially of they are unsure of their citizenship status, or even if they are 100% sure they are citizens.

International adoptees without citizenship have been deported. Learn more about ways to support the Protect Adoptees and Adoptive Families Act to grant citizenship to them and other non-citizen adoptees.

And again, thank you to each person who has read my post, and more importantly, shared this information. May all of us receive due process. May all of us be safe.

Grandparents and Adoption–A New Conversation

I’ve been a grandma for almost 20 years now. I have had 26 cumulative years of grandparenting if I add up my three granddaughters.

As my children, all adopted, grew up, I had many opportunities to learn about adoption, through my lived experience and through professional work and training. My grandchildren are not adopted. They, like their parents, are people of color; I am white. As is true for my children, my grandchildren have no biological connection to me. Adoption affects them even so, through their parents. Add into that their genetic ancestors, some known, some unknown.

I’ve thought lots about how adoption affects me as a grandparent, and how it affects my grandchildren. I know many adult adoptees who are grandparents–they have a biological connection to their grandkids, though they may not have any connection with their own birth parents and other relatives. I know grandparents whose grandchildren were placed for adoption, and who no longer have any connection to their grandkids. I know grandparents whose grandchildren are adopted.

Grandparents and adoption–that’s the Substack link, and there’s a lot to talk about.

I’ll be providing ideas, information, and resources. I plan to host online sessions with a variety of grandparents who have a connection with adoption. We will take a look at the nature of loss, love, joy, race, trauma, healing, grief, laughter, and understanding, all in the context of adoption and grandparenting.

Please take a look, and feel free to share. You can subscribe for free; you can donate to the cause. I welcome your thoughts, questions, insights. Thank you!

https://substack.com/@grandparentsandadoption

New Legislation Introduced for Adoptee Citizenship

Legislation has been introduced in the U.S. House of Representatives and Senate to grant citizenship to all international adoptees.

Please contact your Congressional representatives and ask them to co-sponsor the “Protect Adoptees and American Families Act,” PAAF.

Proponents of the bill have for years focused on a bipartisan effort.

The bill introduced in the House by Rep. Adam Smith (D-WA) and Rep. Don Bacon (R-NE) is H.R. 5492.

In the Senate, the co-sponsors of S. 2923 are Sen. Maizie Hirono (D-HI) and Sen. Susan Collins (R-ME)

Here is a statement by Sen. Hirono:

Adoptees United has solid information here about PAAF.

Next steps could be hearings in the Judiciary Committees of both chambers, then passage in both the House and Senate, and then signature into law by the president.

That’s certainly my hope. Thousands of international adoptees, brought to this country to join new families, did not automatically receive citizenship because their parents failed to get it or because of bureaucratic errors. This reality has been an untenable, unfair reality that the Congress has taken far too long to rectify. This legislation has been previously introduced over the last 10 years, though it has not passed. It would provide a long overdue correction, one wanted by the sending countries, by the adoption community, and by adoptees.

It seems amazing that, for decades, international adoptees were not granted automatic citizenship when they were adopted by U.S. citizens and arrived in the U.S. You can learn more here.

IMG_1734

Some folks might forget that international adoptees are immigrants, with all the complexity that immigration involves. I urge all adoptees and their families to make sure they have a Certificate of Citizenship. A passport is a limited means of proving citizenship, can expire, and is issued by the U.S. State Department, The Certificate of Citizenship is issued by the U.S. Department of Homeland Security, and does not expire. State and Homeland Security use separate databases, and so having a passport may not be adequate proof of citizenship for some purposes.

And the current cost of the Certificate for adoptees is 0, which is wonderful and could change. More info on the fee schedule for the N-600 is here.

You may never need the CoC. I get that. But the parents of deported adoptees (those convicted of a felony and without citizenship) probably never envisioned their children subject to deportation either. Nor, of course, did the adoptees themselves, including those who have been deported to Germany, Korea, Brazil, and elsewhere, who are sitting in U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement detention centers, or who are unable to vote or get financial aid because they have no proof of citizenship. Why risk it?

And please support the passage of the Protect Adoptees and American Families Act. It is long overdue, and it is the right thing to do. Thank you.